Difference between revisions of "The MUSETECH Model"

From CLIO
 
(9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The MUSETECH Model<ref>https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3297717</ref> posits that in order for museums to successfully utilize technologies, there are three stakeholder perspectives that must be considered.  Throughout all stages of a museum technology project, these perspectives offer views that complement and inform the others in a way that can build institutional synergy. This model also states that there are four primary stages or constituents of a museum technology project.  These quartiles contain evaluation criteria per perspective, grouped by thematic categories called clusters, which allows for a granular overview of the considerations throughout each stage of the technology project.
The MUSETECH Model<ref>https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3297717</ref> posits that in order for museums to successfully utilize technologies, there are three stakeholder perspectives that must be considered: the museum as an institution, the cultural heritage professionals who interpret its collections, and the visitors who use these resources.  Throughout all stages of a museum technology project, these perspectives offer views that complement and inform the others in a way that can build institutional synergy. This model also states that there are four primary stages or constituents of a museum technology project: design, content, operation, and compliance.  These quartiles contain evaluation criteria per perspective, grouped by thematic categories, which allows for a granular overview of the considerations throughout each stage of the technology project.


==Navigating the Model==
==Navigating the Model==
Line 25: Line 25:
This stage regards the ideation of the technology project, its interaction methods, user experience, and aesthetics.
This stage regards the ideation of the technology project, its interaction methods, user experience, and aesthetics.


{|style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #ccb7e5;"| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #ccb7e5;" |
|-
|-
! style="background-color:#ccb7e5;" |Cluster
! style="background-color:#ccb7e5;" |Cluster
Line 149: Line 149:
This stage regards content creation and management for the technology project.
This stage regards content creation and management for the technology project.


{| class="wikitable" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #a4c3d2;" |
{| class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #a4c3d2;" |
! rowspan="2" style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Quartile
! rowspan="2" style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Cluster
! colspan="3" style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Evaluation Criteria
|-
|-
! style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
! style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Cluster
! style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Museum
! style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Perspective
! style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" | Visitor
! style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |Evaluation Criteria
|-
|-
| rowspan="10" style="background-color:#a4c3d2;" |'''Content'''
| rowspan="11" style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |'''C1.''' Content Creation
| rowspan="7" style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |'''C1.''' Content Creation
| rowspan="7" style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pa|'''C1Pa.''' Utility, usability and ease of use]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pa|'''C1Pa.''' Utility, usability and ease of use]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Ma|'''C1Ma.''' Continuity of usage]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Va|'''C1Va.''' Perceived content quality]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pb|'''C1Pb.''' Learnability and learning curve]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pb|'''C1Pb.''' Learnability and learning curve]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Mb|'''C1Mb.''' Logging]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Vb|'''C1Vb.''' Visitor-created content, creation and curation]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pc|'''C1Pc.''' Personalization and adaptation]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pc|'''C1Pc.''' Personalization and adaptation]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pd|'''C1Pd.''' Multilingualism]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pd|'''C1Pd.''' Multilingualism]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pe|'''C1Pe.''' Community support]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pe|'''C1Pe.''' Community support]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pf|'''C1Pf.''' Technology knowledge and support in the house]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pf|'''C1Pf.''' Technology knowledge and support in the house]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pg|'''C1Pg.''' Interoperability]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Pg|'''C1Pg.''' Interoperability]]
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
| style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |
|-
|-
| rowspan="3" style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |'''C2.''' Content Maintenance
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |Museum
|style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Ma|'''C1Ma.''' Continuity of usage]]
|-
|style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Mb|'''C1Mb.''' Logging]]
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |Visitor
|style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Va|'''C1Va.''' Perceived content quality]]
|-
|style="background-color:#bfd4db;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C1Vb|'''C1Vb.''' Visitor-created content, creation and curation]]
|-
| rowspan="7" style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |'''C2.''' Content Maintenance
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Pa|'''C2Pa.''' Ability to make changes in-house]]
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Pa|'''C2Pa.''' Ability to make changes in-house]]
|-
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Pb|'''C2Pb.''' Potential for documenting and archiving]]
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |Museum
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Ma|'''C2Ma.''' Staff acceptance]]
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Ma|'''C2Ma.''' Staff acceptance]]
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Va|'''C2Va.''' Personalization]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Pb|'''C2Pb.''' Potential for documenting and archiving]]
|style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Mb|'''C2Mb.''' Interoperability and modularity]]
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Mb|'''C2Mb.''' Interoperability and modularity]]
|-
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Vb|'''C2Vb.''' Social interaction and sharing]]
| rowspan="3" style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |Visitor
|style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Va|'''C2Va.''' Personalization]]
|-
|style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Vb|'''C2Vb.''' Social interaction and sharing]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |
|style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Vc|'''C2Vc.''' Continuity of usage]]
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |
| style="background-color:#aecbd6;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#C2Vc|'''C2Vc.''' Continuity of usage]]
|}
|}


Line 205: Line 203:
This stage regards the logistics of running and maintaining the technology project through its lifetime and beyond.
This stage regards the logistics of running and maintaining the technology project through its lifetime and beyond.


{| class="wikitable" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #ff8986;" |
{| class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #ff8986;" |
! rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Quartile
! rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Cluster
! colspan="3" style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Evaluation Criteria
|-
|-
! style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
! style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Cluster
! style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Museum
! style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Perspective
! style="background-color:#ff8986;" | Visitor
! style="background-color:#ff8986;" |Evaluation Criteria
|-
|-
| rowspan="14" style="background-color:#ff8986;" |'''Operation'''
| rowspan="11" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |'''O1.''' Deployment and setting-up
| rowspan="5" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |'''O1.''' Deployment and setting-up
| rowspan="5" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pa|'''O1Pa.''' Ease of use for installation]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pa|'''O1Pa.''' Ease of use for installation]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Ma|'''O1Ma.''' Set-up and start up]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Va|'''O1Va.''' Visitor experience quality and customer care]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pb|'''O1Pb.''' Distance monitoring]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pb|'''O1Pb.''' Distance monitoring]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Mb|'''O1Mb.''' Modularity and interoperability]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Vb|'''O1Vb.''' Visitor-owned devices]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pc|'''O1Pc.''' Workflow]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pc|'''O1Pc.''' Workflow]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Mc|'''O1Mc.''' Staff and front-desk training]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pd|'''O1Pd.''' In-house technical knowledge]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" | [[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pd|'''O1Pd.''' In-house technical knowledge]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" | [[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Md|'''O1Md.''' Distribution, recovery and guarantee]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pe|'''O1Pe.''' Additional staff training]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Pe|'''O1Pe.''' Additional staff training]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |
|-
|-
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |'''O2.''' Robustness and Maintenance
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;"  |Museum
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Ma|'''O1Ma.''' Set-up and start up]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Mb|'''O1Mb.''' Modularity and interoperability]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Mc|'''O1Mc.''' Staff and front-desk training]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Md|'''O1Md.''' Distribution, recovery and guarantee]]
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;"  |Visitor
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Va|'''O1Va.''' Visitor experience quality and customer care]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O1Vb|'''O1Vb.''' Visitor-owned devices]]
|-
| rowspan="12" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |'''O2.''' Robustness and Maintenance
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pa|'''O2Pa.''' Environmental constraints]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pa|'''O2Pa.''' Environmental constraints]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Ma|'''O2Ma.''' Storage cost]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Va|'''O2Va.''' Robustness]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pb|'''O2Pb.''' Robustness]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pb|'''O2Pb.''' Robustness]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Mb|'''O2Mb.''' Level of maintenance]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Vb|'''O2Vb.''' Responsiveness]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pc|'''O2Pc.''' Maintenance required]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pc|'''O2Pc.''' Maintenance required]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Mc|'''O2Mc.''' Loss, deterioration, theft and replacement]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Vc|'''O2Vc.''' Stability]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pd|'''O2Pd.''' Updating and replacing]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Pd|'''O2Pd.''' Updating and replacing]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Md|'''O2Md.''' Reusing and disposing]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Vd|'''O2Vd.''' Speed and speed of recovery]]
|-
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |'''O3.''' Power and Energy
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |Museum
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Ma|'''O2Ma.''' Storage cost]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Mb|'''O2Mb.''' Level of maintenance]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Mc|'''O2Mc.''' Loss, deterioration, theft and replacement]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Md|'''O2Md.''' Reusing and disposing]]
|-
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |Visitor
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Va|'''O2Va.''' Robustness]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Vb|'''O2Vb.''' Responsiveness]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Vc|'''O2Vc.''' Stability]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O2Vd|'''O2Vd.''' Speed and speed of recovery]]
|-
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |'''O3.''' Power and Energy
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Pa|'''O3Pa.''' Day to day running and maintenance]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Pa|'''O3Pa.''' Day to day running and maintenance]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Ma|'''O3Ma.''' Interventions in the exhibit space]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Va|'''O3Va.''' Prevent feelings of failure and frustration]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Pb|'''O3Pb.''' Stability]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Pb|'''O3Pb.''' Stability]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |
|-
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |'''O4.''' Costs
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |Museum
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Ma|'''O3Ma.''' Interventions in the exhibit space]]
|-
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |Visitor
|style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O3Va|'''O3Va.''' Prevent feelings of failure and frustration]]
|-
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |'''O4.''' Costs
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Pa|'''O4Pa.''' Workforce, time and additional staff]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Pa|'''O4Pa.''' Workforce, time and additional staff]]
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#ff9997;" |Museum
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Ma|'''O4Ma.''' Financial costs and investments]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Ma|'''O4Ma.''' Financial costs and investments]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Va|'''O4Va.''' Costs (value for money and time)]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Mb|'''O4Mb.''' Running costs]]
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Mb|'''O4Mb.''' Running costs]]
|-
| style="background-color:#ff9997;" |
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |Visitor
|style="background-color:#ff9997;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O4Va|'''O4Va.''' Costs (value for money and time)]]
|-
| rowspan="3" style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |'''O5.''' Additional Resources
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" | Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O5Pa|'''O5Pa.''' Instructions and how-to guides]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |'''O5.''' Additional Resources
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |Museum
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" | [[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O5Pa|'''O5Pa.''' Instructions and how-to guides]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O5Ma|'''O5Ma.''' Adopting, financing and sponsoring]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O5Ma|'''O5Ma.''' Adopting, financing and sponsoring]]
|-
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |Visitor
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O5Va|'''O5Va.''' Uptake]]
| style="background-color:#ffa9a9;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#O5Va|'''O5Va.''' Uptake]]
|}
|}
Line 280: Line 301:
This stages covers ethical and legal considerations regarding health, safety, and liability as they relate to the technology project.
This stages covers ethical and legal considerations regarding health, safety, and liability as they relate to the technology project.


{| class="wikitable" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #a7e99c;" |
{| class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 2px; border-color: #a7e99c;" |
! rowspan="2" style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Quartile
! style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Cluster
! rowspan="2" style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Cluster
! style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Perspective
! colspan="3" style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Evaluation Criteria
! style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Evaluation Criteria
|-
|-
! style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| rowspan="10" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |'''MP1.''' Health, Safety and Accessibility
! style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Museum
| rowspan="3" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
! style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |Visitor
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Pa|'''MP1Pa.''' Accessibility]]
|-
|-
| rowspan="8" style="background-color:#a7e99c;" |'''Compliance'''
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Pb|'''MP1Pb.''' Appropriateness]]
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |'''MP1.''' Health, Safety and Accessibility
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Pa|'''MP1Pa.''' Accessibility]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Pc|'''MP1Pc.''' Safety]]
|-
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |Museum
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Ma|'''MP1Ma.''' Safety]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Ma|'''MP1Ma.''' Safety]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Va|'''MP1Va.''' Accessibility]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Pb|'''MP1Pb.''' Appropriateness]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Mb|'''MP1Mb.''' Emergency management]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Mb|'''MP1Mb.''' Emergency management]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Vb|'''MP1Vb.''' Appropriateness]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Pc|'''MP1Pc.''' Safety]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Mc|'''MP1Mc.''' Disposal and recycling]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Mc|'''MP1Mc.''' Disposal and recycling]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Vc|'''MP1Vc.''' Safety]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Md|'''MP1Md.''' Hygiene, cleaning and maintenance]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Md|'''MP1Md.''' Hygiene, cleaning and maintenance]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |
|-
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |'''MP2.''' Logging and Monitoring
| rowspan="3"  style="background-color:#d7f4d2;"  |Visitor
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Va|'''MP1Va.''' Accessibility]]
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Vb|'''MP1Vb.''' Appropriateness]]
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP1Vc|'''MP1Vc.''' Safety]]
|-
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |'''MP2.''' Logging and Monitoring
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Pa|'''MP2Pa.''' Logging and monitoring]]
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Pa|'''MP2Pa.''' Logging and monitoring]]
|-
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |Museum
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Ma|'''MP2Ma.''' Log storage, access, privacy and analytics]]
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Ma|'''MP2Ma.''' Log storage, access, privacy and analytics]]
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Va|'''MP2Va.''' Personalization]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |Visitor
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |
|style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Va|'''MP2Va.''' Personalization]]
| style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Vb|'''MP2Vb.''' Legal compliance]]
|-
|style="background-color:#bfeeb7;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP2Vb|'''MP2Vb.''' Legal compliance]]
|-
|-
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |'''MP3.''' Ethics and Legal Issues
| rowspan="4" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |'''MP3.''' Ethics and Legal Issues
| rowspan="2" style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |Cultural Heritage Professional
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Pa|'''MP3Pa.''' Protecting audiences]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Pa|'''MP3Pa.''' Protecting audiences]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Ma|'''MP3Ma.''' Other legal issues]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Va|'''MP3Va.''' Trust and confidence in museum]]
|-
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Pb|'''MP3Pb.''' Data gathering and protection]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Pb|'''MP3Pb.''' Data gathering and protection]]
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |
|-
| style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |
|style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |Museum
|style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Ma|'''MP3Ma.''' Other legal issues]]
|-
|style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |Visitor
|style="background-color:#d7f4d2;" |[[MUSETECH_Evaluation_Criteria_by_Cluster#MP3Va|'''MP3Va.''' Trust and confidence in museum]]
|}
|}


Latest revision as of 18:01, 24 February 2023

The MUSETECH Model[1] posits that in order for museums to successfully utilize technologies, there are three stakeholder perspectives that must be considered: the museum as an institution, the cultural heritage professionals who interpret its collections, and the visitors who use these resources. Throughout all stages of a museum technology project, these perspectives offer views that complement and inform the others in a way that can build institutional synergy. This model also states that there are four primary stages or constituents of a museum technology project: design, content, operation, and compliance. These quartiles contain evaluation criteria per perspective, grouped by thematic categories, which allows for a granular overview of the considerations throughout each stage of the technology project.

Navigating the Model

(EC) Evaluation Criteria

There are a total of 121 Evaluation Criteria that provide a granular overview of the project for the museum as an institution, cultural heritage professionals and visitors.

Read more.png


Coordinates

Each Evaluation Criteria is assigned a unique ID, making it easier to address specific areas of the matrix. Each Evaluation Criteria is listed by Quartile, Cluster, Perspective and Evaluation Criteria. For example, D1Pa refers to the “Design Quartile”, “Cluster 1: Design and product ideation” for the “Cultural Heritage Professional”, Evaluation Criteria “a”.

Perspectives

(M) Museum as an Institution

This addresses the needs of the institution as it exists interdependently with the Cultural Heritage Professionals it employs and the Visitors that utilize its resources.

(CHP) Cultural Heritage Professional

This addresses the needs of professionals who works within a Museum institution, regardless of their department or title. These professionals perform a large portion of the interactions with Visitors and often create content through utilization of the Museum’s resources.

(V) Visitor

This addresses the needs of individuals who are accessing the Museum’s resources by utilizing content created through a Cultural Heritage Professional, in both self-directed or facilitated interactions.

Quartiles

(D) Design

This stage regards the ideation of the technology project, its interaction methods, user experience, and aesthetics.

Cluster Perspective Evaluation Criteria
D1. Design and Product Ideation Cultural Heritage Professional D1Pa. Design Concept
D1Pb. Integration with Exhibition
D1Pc. Integration with other ICT
D1Pd. Balancing Physical with Digital
D1Pe. Understanding the Fabrication Process
D1Pf. In-house technical knowledge
Museum D1Ma. Level of Innovation and business intelligence
D1Mb. Brand name, uniqueness, originality
D1Mc. Integration with other ICT
D1Md. Budget
D1Me. Staff acceptance
Visitor D1Va. Co-design, front-end evaluation and visitor acceptance
D2. Experience Design and Narratives Cultural Heritage Professional D2Pa. Experience added value
D2Pb. Relevance to audience
D2Pc. Tailored content
D2Pd. Attentional balance
D2Pe. Social interaction
D2Pf. Before and after the visit support
Museum D2Ma. Interpretive, educational and learning potential
D2Mb. Personalization potential
D2Mc. Public outreach and communication
D2Md. Big data potential
Visitor D2Va. Engagement
D2Vb. Personalization
D2Vc. Learning, entertainment and edutainment
D2Vd. Attentional balance
D2Ve. Affective impact
D2Vf. Social interaction
D2Vg. Ability to follow usage on other platforms
D2Vh. Sense of belonging to a community
D3. Interactions, Affordances and Interaction Metaphors Cultural Heritage Professional D3Pa. Quality of Affordances
D3Pb. Suitability of interaction metaphors
D3Pc. Interface design
D3Pd. Clarity of navigation
D3Pe. Follow-up usage on other platforms
D3Pf. Multisensoriality
Museum D3Ma. Follow-up usage on other platforms
D3Mb. Brand name, uniqueness and originality
Visitor D3Va. Utility, usability and ease of use
D3Vb. Intuitiveness, learnability and learning curve
D3Vc. Responsiveness
D3Vd. Clarity of navigation
D3Ve. Personalization
D3Vf. Social interaction
D3Vg. Ability to follow-up usage on other platforms
D3Vh. Presence of Multisensoriality
D4. Aesthetics, Look and Feel, and Visceral Qualities Cultural Heritage Professional D4Pa. Look and feel
Museum D4Ma. Brand name, uniqueness and originality
Visitor D4Va. Look and feel

(C) Content

This stage regards content creation and management for the technology project.

Cluster Perspective Evaluation Criteria
C1. Content Creation Cultural Heritage Professional C1Pa. Utility, usability and ease of use
C1Pb. Learnability and learning curve
C1Pc. Personalization and adaptation
C1Pd. Multilingualism
C1Pe. Community support
C1Pf. Technology knowledge and support in the house
C1Pg. Interoperability
Museum C1Ma. Continuity of usage
C1Mb. Logging
Visitor C1Va. Perceived content quality
C1Vb. Visitor-created content, creation and curation
C2. Content Maintenance Cultural Heritage Professional C2Pa. Ability to make changes in-house
C2Pb. Potential for documenting and archiving
Museum C2Ma. Staff acceptance
C2Mb. Interoperability and modularity
Visitor C2Va. Personalization
C2Vb. Social interaction and sharing
C2Vc. Continuity of usage

(O) Operation

This stage regards the logistics of running and maintaining the technology project through its lifetime and beyond.

Cluster Perspective Evaluation Criteria
O1. Deployment and setting-up Cultural Heritage Professional O1Pa. Ease of use for installation
O1Pb. Distance monitoring
O1Pc. Workflow
O1Pd. In-house technical knowledge
O1Pe. Additional staff training
Museum O1Ma. Set-up and start up
O1Mb. Modularity and interoperability
O1Mc. Staff and front-desk training
O1Md. Distribution, recovery and guarantee
Visitor O1Va. Visitor experience quality and customer care
O1Vb. Visitor-owned devices
O2. Robustness and Maintenance Cultural Heritage Professional O2Pa. Environmental constraints
O2Pb. Robustness
O2Pc. Maintenance required
O2Pd. Updating and replacing
Museum O2Ma. Storage cost
O2Mb. Level of maintenance
O2Mc. Loss, deterioration, theft and replacement
O2Md. Reusing and disposing
Visitor O2Va. Robustness
O2Vb. Responsiveness
O2Vc. Stability
O2Vd. Speed and speed of recovery
O3. Power and Energy Cultural Heritage Professional O3Pa. Day to day running and maintenance
O3Pb. Stability
Museum O3Ma. Interventions in the exhibit space
Visitor O3Va. Prevent feelings of failure and frustration
O4. Costs Cultural Heritage Professional O4Pa. Workforce, time and additional staff
Museum O4Ma. Financial costs and investments
O4Mb. Running costs
Visitor O4Va. Costs (value for money and time)
O5. Additional Resources Cultural Heritage Professional O5Pa. Instructions and how-to guides
Museum O5Ma. Adopting, financing and sponsoring
Visitor O5Va. Uptake

(MP) Compliance

This stages covers ethical and legal considerations regarding health, safety, and liability as they relate to the technology project.

Cluster Perspective Evaluation Criteria
MP1. Health, Safety and Accessibility Cultural Heritage Professional MP1Pa. Accessibility
MP1Pb. Appropriateness
MP1Pc. Safety
Museum MP1Ma. Safety
MP1Mb. Emergency management
MP1Mc. Disposal and recycling
MP1Md. Hygiene, cleaning and maintenance
Visitor MP1Va. Accessibility
MP1Vb. Appropriateness
MP1Vc. Safety
MP2. Logging and Monitoring Cultural Heritage Professional MP2Pa. Logging and monitoring
Museum MP2Ma. Log storage, access, privacy and analytics
Visitor MP2Va. Personalization
MP2Vb. Legal compliance
MP3. Ethics and Legal Issues Cultural Heritage Professional MP3Pa. Protecting audiences
MP3Pb. Data gathering and protection
Museum MP3Ma. Other legal issues
Visitor MP3Va. Trust and confidence in museum

References

  1. ↑ https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3297717
Retrieved from "https://wiki.interpretive.tech/index.php?title=The_MUSETECH_Model&oldid=1856"